The goal of this blog is to spark communication, debate, controversy and ideas in the field of laser surgery. A Message from our Moderator:
Learn More
AnthonyDurkin, PhD PhD.
Assistant Professor at the Beckman Laser Institute in the School of Medicine at UC Irvine,
View Bio
Dr. Eric F. Bernstein M.D.
Associate Clinical Professor of Dermatology University of Pennsylvania,
View Bio
Dr. Roy G. Geronemus M.D.
Director, Laser & Skin Surgery Center of New York,
View Bio
Dr. Melanie Grossman M.D.
Clinical Instructor, Columbia Presbyterian Medical Center,
View Bio
Dr. Suzanne L. Kilmer M.D.
Director, Laser and Skin Surgery Center of Northern California,
View Bio
Dr. Victor Ross M.D.
Director, Laser & Cosmetic Dermatology Unit, Scripps Clinic in San Diego.,
View Bio
Dr. Christopher B. Zachary M.D. FRCP
Professor and Chair, Department of Dermatology, University of California, Irvine,
View Bio
Dr. Brian Zelickson M.D.
Director, Zel Skin & Laser Specialists, Minneapolis,
View Bio

 
American Academy of Dermatology
 
American Society for Dermatologic Surgery
 
American Society for Laser Medicine and Surgery
Posted by
Eric Bernstein, M.D.
Associate Clinical Professor of Dermatology University of Pennsylvania
Post (9)
View Bio
Commandment #6: I Do Not Use IPL

See Commandment #1. I do not use intense pulsed light sources in my practice because I believe:

  1. It is harder to predict results with IPL
  2. IPLs are not safe to use around the eye
  3. The risk of burning the skin is greater than with lasers due to difficulty in predicting outcomes when using multiple wavelengths
  4. Filtering the light so it is not too bright for the user’s eyes is difficult or impossible


The user can’t protect themselves from the light effectively enough for me, especially when there are effective and safe lasers for the various conditions in which they are used. I also never use IPLs to treat tattoos, not ever. As far as I know, it is impossible to filter these devices so that a single wavelength of light comes out at energies useful in cutaneous laser surgery as does when one uses a laser. Therefore, in my opinion, it is much harder to predict the outcome in a given patient in terms of side-effects and effectiveness.

In addition, broad-spectrum light sources are less predictable within a patient and between patients than is monochromatic light. People buy these devices to try to treat every condition with one machine or to treat a patient faster-which translates into an attempt to save money when purchasing a machine. In my opinion, this is a mistake in the aesthetic field. I believe folks should buy the device that best treats the conditions they are going to be seeing most frequently, and then add machines as their laser practice expands. In the interest of balance (ha, ha!)I would like to re-emphasize the positive-IPLs are pretty good when it comes to removing freckles without targeting the individual lesions but when painting a given area, but I don’t use them in my practice.

Posted 2nd January 2009 at 10:43 am in IPL, Laser's 10 Commandments
Comments (0)   |   Add Comments
   
Fat & Lasers
  
Fractional Lasers
Issues and discussions on Fractional Lasers
  
IPL
Debating and Discussing Intense Pulsed Light
  
Laser Hair Removal
Discussion and Debates on Laser Hair Removal.
  
Laser's 10 Commandments
The Top Ten Considerations of Laser Medicine as developed by Eric.
  
Product Warnings
  
Skin Rejuvenation
  
Tattoo Removal
  
The Business of Laser Medicine
  
Well said.

J-Man on Commandment #7: Tattoo Removal Requires Multiple Lasers